5 Mistakes Wealthy Families Make in Philanthropy and How to Avoid Them
Family philanthropy has the power to define a legacy across generations. But without clarity, even generous giving can become fragmented, weakening the impact of their charitable giving.
Too often, affluent families approach philanthropy as a series of transactions rather than a long-term strategy. The result? Disconnected giving, missed opportunities, and unclear impact.
Philanthropy at its best is guided not only by generosity but by vision and clarity. Research shows values drive giving more than anything else, yet many families default to reactive cues: recognizable brands, a compelling gala, or social pressure from peers. Legacy requires more. It requires explicit values, structures, and storytelling to ensure wealth carries meaning, not just money.
The Five Mistakes to Avoid
1. No Clear Values Defined
Families that skip defining their philanthropic values risk scattershot giving. In 2023, 69.5% of affluent households said personal values guided their giving. Defining and documenting those values ensures that your philanthropy reflects what your family stands for, not just what feels urgent in the moment.
2. Leaving the Next Generation Out
Many wait until heirs inherit wealth to invite them into the conversation. By then, interest and alignment may already be lost. Studies show that family foundations that actively engage the next generation through junior boards, site visits, or shared decision-making are more effective and experience stronger continuity. Involving your children and grandchildren early builds both skill and commitment.
3. Defaulting to Reactive Giving Instead of Strategy
Gala requests, pitches from friends, or headline-driven causes are common triggers for gifts. But reactive giving often dilutes resources and neglects long-term impact. A written philanthropic strategy with clear priorities, goals, and decision criteria separates meaningful legacy from scattered generosity.
4. No Formal Structures or Systems
Without governance, even the wealthiest families can run into conflict, decision paralysis, or ineffectiveness. Whether through a private foundation, a donor-advised fund (DAF), or structured family councils, systems provide clarity and continuity. In 2023, DAFs granted $54.8 billion to nonprofits with an average payout of 23.9% but even the best vehicles are only effective if they’re paired with clear family decision-making protocols.
5. Lack of Storytelling Around the Legacy
Families often pass down money but not meaning. Without a narrative, the why behind the giving, the next generation inherits wealth without the wisdom that shaped it. Legacy letters, oral histories, and family stories ensure that philanthropy becomes a tradition of values, not just a transfer of funds.
Philanthropy done well is not about writing checks; it’s about writing history. When families articulate values, involve the next generation, establish systems, and preserve the story, their wealth creates more than generosity. It creates legacy.
Explore our advisory services or schedule a free call to discuss your needs.
Sources:
Bank of America / Indiana University Lilly Family School of Philanthropy. 2023 Bank of America Study of Philanthropy - https://www.pbig.ml.com/articles/2023-bank-of-america-study-of-philanthropy.html
National Center for Family Philanthropy. Next Gen Philanthropy in 2023. - https://www.ncfp.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Trends-2025%E2%80%94Results-of-the-Third-National-Benchmark-Survey-11.04.24.pdf
FreeWill Nonprofit Resource Center. Donor-Advised Funds 101 (2024 update) - https://www.nonprofits.freewill.com/resources/blog/donor-advised-funds-101
National Philanthropic Trust. 2024 Donor-Advised Fund Report (covering 2023 activity) - https://www.nptrust.org/reports/daf-report/